Am I Good Enough? — God's Standard vs. Ours
TypeApologetics Evidence Document
Use WhenSomeone gets stuck on Gospel Script Q2 — they say they are a good person. This page helps you move from their standard to God's standard without lecturing or shaming.
The Problem with "Good Enough"
When someone says "I'm a good person," they almost always mean one of two things:
- "I'm better than most people." (Comparative goodness)
- "I try hard and mean well." (Intentional goodness)
Both are understandable — but neither addresses the actual question: Am I good enough by God's standard?
The issue is the benchmark. If you compare yourself to a serial killer, you look great. But God doesn't grade on a curve — he compares everyone to the same standard: perfection.
"Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect." — Matthew 5:48
That isn't an impossible ideal Jesus set carelessly. It's a revelation of what a holy God actually is — and what any being who stands before him would need to be.
What God's Standard Actually Is
The Ten Commandments are not ten suggestions. Jesus raised the bar even further in the Sermon on the Mount:
| The Command | God's Standard |
|---|---|
| Do not murder | Even anger toward your brother makes you liable to judgment (Matthew 5:21–22) |
| Do not commit adultery | Even looking with lust is adultery in the heart (Matthew 5:27–28) |
| Do not swear falsely | Let your yes be yes — total honesty always (Matthew 5:37) |
| Love your neighbour | Love your enemies (Matthew 5:44) |
James summarises: "Whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it." (James 2:10)
God's standard is not partial compliance. It is complete and continuous righteousness of heart, not just behaviour.
The Testimony of the Conscience
Even without knowing the Bible, human beings have a built-in moral awareness — what the Bible calls the conscience and what philosophers call the moral sense.
Romans 2:14–15:
"When Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law, they are a law for themselves... their consciences also bearing witness, and their thoughts sometimes accusing them and at other times even defending them."
The conscience is not a reliable guide to holiness — it gets dulled, overridden, and rationalised. But it is evidence that human beings already know there is a standard. That's why:
- People feel guilt
- People make excuses (you only make excuses when you believe a standard applies to you)
- People get angry at injustice, even when it doesn't affect them
Nobody lives as if there is no moral standard. The question is whether you have met it.
Why "Better Than Average" Doesn't Work
Imagine a diving competition judged on whether the diver can touch the bottom of the ocean. Comparing yourself to other divers is irrelevant — what matters is whether anyone can reach the standard.
Or consider a courtroom. A judge does not acquit a thief because the thief is nicer than a murderer. The crime is judged on its own merits — did the person break the law or not?
God's justice works the same way:
- He is not comparing you to Hitler.
- He is comparing you to himself — perfectly holy, perfectly pure, with no shadow of wrongdoing.
Against that standard, the universal conclusion of Scripture is consistent:
"There is no one righteous, not even one; there is no one who understands; there is no one who seeks God." — Romans 3:10–11
"All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God." — Romans 3:23
"If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us." — 1 John 1:8
The Psychological Evidence
Psychologists and anthropologists across cultures have noted the universal phenomenon of guilt — not just social shame, but an internal sense of having violated a genuine moral standard.
- Every known culture has some concept of wrongdoing, punishment, and the need for atonement or reconciliation.
- Cross-cultural studies on moral intuition show agreement on core moral wrongs (murder, theft, betrayal) that cannot be explained purely by social conditioning.
- Guilt differs from shame. Shame is about what others think of you. Guilt is about what you know about yourself. The universality of guilt points to an internal moral standard that is not merely social.
The Bible's claim — that all humans know they are guilty before God — is not a piece of religious dogma. It is a description of human experience that matches what we observe.
How to Use This in Conversation
Don't argue with the claim directly. Instead, shift the standard:
"I'm not doubting that you're a good person compared to most people — I actually think you probably are. But I want to test that against God's standard, not ours. God doesn't grade on a curve. Can I ask you a few specific questions?"
Then move to Q3 (lying), Q4 (God's name), Q5 (anger). Let the specific examples do the work. The goal is not to shame them — it is to help them see that everyone has fallen short of God's standard, which is the only standard that matters for eternity.
The key pivot question:
"By your own standard, have you always done what you know is right?"
Almost no one can say yes. And if they can't meet their own standard, they certainly can't meet God's.
Resources for Further Study
- The Holiness of God — R.C. Sproul
- Mere Christianity, Book 1 — C.S. Lewis ("The Law of Human Nature")
- Romans 1–3 (especially Romans 3:9–23)
← Back to Gospel Script Q2